Last Monday, trust, particularly in our students, left me with a bad taste in my mouth. I couldn’t stop thinking of the different examples of how teachers distrust their students and how, I’m sure, I have done the same. The days following I saw this distrust everywhere. I saw it when a coworker came into the office practically in tears because the in-school-suspension teacher (monitor?) scolded her in front of all of the students and told her (coworker) not to question her (the monitor) in front of students. She also went on to humiliate a student. Not only did she not trust the student, but she didn’t trust an adult to have any valid opinions or questions. I spared the details, the very ugly details, so it may be hard to get the whole picture, but trust that it was a blatant display of utter distrust and it left me feeling sick.
On Friday, I sat in the cafeteria involving students in making holiday cards for troops. Meanwhile a girl had a very expensive birthday cake she was sharing with her friends. After lunch, administrators asked her to take the cake to the front office and then backtracked and asked her to wait until after the passing period. Another teacher decided this wasn’t enough, took the cake and dumped it into the trashcan. Not only was he showing his distrust in the student to complete a simple task, he also created an unnecessary mess for the janitor to clean. I was disgusted.
As a read the intro to What Works, I was able to feel somewhat better about these situations and the everyday incidents of distrust within the classroom. When it comes to curricula, the authors say, “Classroom studies help us resist prepackaged, laminated, hole-punched, ‘teacher-proof’ curricula” (xvii) and “Sharing our findings enables us to trust our teaching practices” (xxiii). These studies or inquires allow teachers to reassert why they do what they do. Before we can trust the students, we have to trust ourselves, which may mean questioning ourselves and our methods. And focusing on the students when we question requires that we begin to understand the layers of influences on their entire being. When we can understand some of these influences, we can trust the students to take control over their learning in a multitude of ways.
This book ease some of my worries and made me feel empowered.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
This book ease some of my worries and made me feel empowered.
I completely agree? Are you going to do your research proposal on "trust" in the classroom? I find that to be really interesting.
I'm sorry to hear that Sara. How disheartening for all in involved. You make such a point, that we must first trust ourselves, set the model, live the expectation before we can expect this to permeate all teacher behavior. It's so hard to develop trust when we're managed in such a way that we get to school and close our doors and it's ok. It would be interesting to see how many time space in created for teachers to interact in one day in addition to how often we initiate positive/trusting interactions with other teachers..
Your school is so luck to have you!
Sara,
Thank you for sharing your personal experiences in a school this week regarding the idea of trust. I think what you described also involves the complex idea of respect.
What made that teacher think it was okay to throw away a student's cake in the cafeteria? Why do teachers feel the need to flaunt their power in such disrespectful ways?
If you haven't read Angela Valenzuela's Subtractive Schooling, I would definitely recommend it. She discusses our need for reciprocal relationships. It might help if you're interested in exploring this idea further....
Post a Comment