Where do I begin? Reinventing English, small as it is, offers so much and links it all, I think, so well. I remember one of my DP (Teaching Diverse Populations) classes in undergrad, the book divided into chapters on race and ethnicity, sex and sexuality, age, religion, etc. I remember all of the classes emphasizing multicultural education. All of these classes reiterated, "It’s not just about food and holidays." But none of them delved into the gritty stuff. None of these classes discussed how to really challenge students’ thoughts and prejudices.
I really enjoyed how Gaughan merged teaching strategies (centers, four circles) with curricula with real teaching experiences with real student samples with major issues.
I apologize, my thoughts are sporadic.
When Gaughan recounts Katie and how "Becoming aware of the discriminations that surrounds her will help Katie control her own destiny, but she has to believe that discrimination exists in the first place" (71), I am reminded of a girl who despite all of our discussions refuses to believe the possibility of being a victim of sexual abuse. The fact that 1 in 6 women will be raped before entering college is not enough to make her reevaluate her thoughts. She is tough she can fight off one man. So I heighten the threat to two men; she can fight them off. Three, fight that much harder, everything around you is a weapon. I admire her attitude, but how can she be proactive (by not drinking too much, staying out of certain situations, etc.) if she doesn’t believe she could be raped? I struggled with her, and several of the girls in this particular group. I often felt as though I was making no difference at all. What good is this group if they are unwilling to change their beliefs? I have to say I felt better reading the accounts in Reinventing English. Several of his students held true to their beliefs, but a spark of understanding was apparent in their writing. The door to the topic was open, and sometimes that is all we can do.
Sunday, November 25, 2007
Sunday, November 18, 2007
What Works
Last Monday, trust, particularly in our students, left me with a bad taste in my mouth. I couldn’t stop thinking of the different examples of how teachers distrust their students and how, I’m sure, I have done the same. The days following I saw this distrust everywhere. I saw it when a coworker came into the office practically in tears because the in-school-suspension teacher (monitor?) scolded her in front of all of the students and told her (coworker) not to question her (the monitor) in front of students. She also went on to humiliate a student. Not only did she not trust the student, but she didn’t trust an adult to have any valid opinions or questions. I spared the details, the very ugly details, so it may be hard to get the whole picture, but trust that it was a blatant display of utter distrust and it left me feeling sick.
On Friday, I sat in the cafeteria involving students in making holiday cards for troops. Meanwhile a girl had a very expensive birthday cake she was sharing with her friends. After lunch, administrators asked her to take the cake to the front office and then backtracked and asked her to wait until after the passing period. Another teacher decided this wasn’t enough, took the cake and dumped it into the trashcan. Not only was he showing his distrust in the student to complete a simple task, he also created an unnecessary mess for the janitor to clean. I was disgusted.
As a read the intro to What Works, I was able to feel somewhat better about these situations and the everyday incidents of distrust within the classroom. When it comes to curricula, the authors say, “Classroom studies help us resist prepackaged, laminated, hole-punched, ‘teacher-proof’ curricula” (xvii) and “Sharing our findings enables us to trust our teaching practices” (xxiii). These studies or inquires allow teachers to reassert why they do what they do. Before we can trust the students, we have to trust ourselves, which may mean questioning ourselves and our methods. And focusing on the students when we question requires that we begin to understand the layers of influences on their entire being. When we can understand some of these influences, we can trust the students to take control over their learning in a multitude of ways.
This book ease some of my worries and made me feel empowered.
On Friday, I sat in the cafeteria involving students in making holiday cards for troops. Meanwhile a girl had a very expensive birthday cake she was sharing with her friends. After lunch, administrators asked her to take the cake to the front office and then backtracked and asked her to wait until after the passing period. Another teacher decided this wasn’t enough, took the cake and dumped it into the trashcan. Not only was he showing his distrust in the student to complete a simple task, he also created an unnecessary mess for the janitor to clean. I was disgusted.
As a read the intro to What Works, I was able to feel somewhat better about these situations and the everyday incidents of distrust within the classroom. When it comes to curricula, the authors say, “Classroom studies help us resist prepackaged, laminated, hole-punched, ‘teacher-proof’ curricula” (xvii) and “Sharing our findings enables us to trust our teaching practices” (xxiii). These studies or inquires allow teachers to reassert why they do what they do. Before we can trust the students, we have to trust ourselves, which may mean questioning ourselves and our methods. And focusing on the students when we question requires that we begin to understand the layers of influences on their entire being. When we can understand some of these influences, we can trust the students to take control over their learning in a multitude of ways.
This book ease some of my worries and made me feel empowered.
Sunday, November 11, 2007
Reconceptulalizing Part 2
Chapter 9:
"Change takes time" is no longer an applicable idiom. How do we keep up with the changes (I know I haven't been very successful) and give students the tools to keep up with the change?
When I think about school systems and politics I often think about the opportunities I missed out on as a result of the social class into which I was born, and thus the opportunities missed by today's students from lower classes. I almost never, however, think about what students in upper classes miss out on. Their schools may offer tools and skills for "shape-shifting" but they leave students oblivious to social injustice and inequalities. To what extent are teachers responsible for involving privileged students in authentic diversity discourses. In the past few months I have met a handful of people who, as adults, are now struggling with understanding their role in our complex society as privileged white people. They feel "white guilt" for the first time in their lives. For the first time in their lives they are considering issues that others begin to deal with as children. In schools that are inherently not diverse, how do we expose students to diversity and reality? How do we clarify that the goal is not to become "worldly" but critical of out world?
Chapter 10:
Interesting how once again we see students from working class families responding in personal ways while students from middle class families have detached responses.
This chapter brought up several issues with technology that I have had. I have been skeptical of using the Internet as an answer to struggling readers. I also struggle with what it entails to be computer/Internet literate. Does knowing how to download and watch music videos actually indicate that students are Internet literate?
The accounts of the searches for information in the two classes revealed my exact problems with using technology solely as replacements for print-based information sources. Those struggling with print literacy struggle with Internet inquires. So these are the implications I gathered to keep on the forefront of my mind:
1. Incorporate other forms of technology and uses for Internet.
2. Build background of other ways to find information (encyclopedia.com) rather than allowing students to rely on search engines.
3. Use technology and print together to help each other, not just as a substitute for the other.
4. Invite students to do more than just change wall paper.
5. Asses how this is actually helping students.
6. Take advantage of available technology (it's so easy to not).
Chapter 12:
Teachers' refusal to reevaluate and restructure curriculum and methods really does reveal a lack of respect for students. It is eye-opening and sad to think of it this way.
In terms of research, the authors are correct in that "This business of who gets represented and how in our research texts is a tricky one" (238). There is too much influencing and informing one situation to include every point of view. I see the focus on teachers as convenient (one instead of 30) and indicative of the fact that how teachers teach shows their respect/disrespect for students. Thus, it is worth closely examining the teacher. I understand the authors' point and I believe it essential to examine the view/voice of the students, but I don't find it necessary to read "nearly wholly fictionalized" accounts. I'd rather spend my time reading real accounts.
The following chapter seems to focused on teacher and drawing the connection between teacher development and student needs. This should be interesting . . .
"Change takes time" is no longer an applicable idiom. How do we keep up with the changes (I know I haven't been very successful) and give students the tools to keep up with the change?
When I think about school systems and politics I often think about the opportunities I missed out on as a result of the social class into which I was born, and thus the opportunities missed by today's students from lower classes. I almost never, however, think about what students in upper classes miss out on. Their schools may offer tools and skills for "shape-shifting" but they leave students oblivious to social injustice and inequalities. To what extent are teachers responsible for involving privileged students in authentic diversity discourses. In the past few months I have met a handful of people who, as adults, are now struggling with understanding their role in our complex society as privileged white people. They feel "white guilt" for the first time in their lives. For the first time in their lives they are considering issues that others begin to deal with as children. In schools that are inherently not diverse, how do we expose students to diversity and reality? How do we clarify that the goal is not to become "worldly" but critical of out world?
Chapter 10:
Interesting how once again we see students from working class families responding in personal ways while students from middle class families have detached responses.
This chapter brought up several issues with technology that I have had. I have been skeptical of using the Internet as an answer to struggling readers. I also struggle with what it entails to be computer/Internet literate. Does knowing how to download and watch music videos actually indicate that students are Internet literate?
The accounts of the searches for information in the two classes revealed my exact problems with using technology solely as replacements for print-based information sources. Those struggling with print literacy struggle with Internet inquires. So these are the implications I gathered to keep on the forefront of my mind:
1. Incorporate other forms of technology and uses for Internet.
2. Build background of other ways to find information (encyclopedia.com) rather than allowing students to rely on search engines.
3. Use technology and print together to help each other, not just as a substitute for the other.
4. Invite students to do more than just change wall paper.
5. Asses how this is actually helping students.
6. Take advantage of available technology (it's so easy to not).
Chapter 12:
Teachers' refusal to reevaluate and restructure curriculum and methods really does reveal a lack of respect for students. It is eye-opening and sad to think of it this way.
In terms of research, the authors are correct in that "This business of who gets represented and how in our research texts is a tricky one" (238). There is too much influencing and informing one situation to include every point of view. I see the focus on teachers as convenient (one instead of 30) and indicative of the fact that how teachers teach shows their respect/disrespect for students. Thus, it is worth closely examining the teacher. I understand the authors' point and I believe it essential to examine the view/voice of the students, but I don't find it necessary to read "nearly wholly fictionalized" accounts. I'd rather spend my time reading real accounts.
The following chapter seems to focused on teacher and drawing the connection between teacher development and student needs. This should be interesting . . .
Monday, November 5, 2007
Reconceptualizing
Reconceptualizing the Literacies in Adolescents’ Lives
Chapter 1:
“The text or texts, as the adolescents themselves, resist stasis and defy definition” (p.6). I love how true that is. This chapter seemed to attempt to define David and El in terms of their literate life at any particular point in their life, but they couldn’t be defined. Changes could be identified in the two, but there were so many different influences at any one time that it was impossible to clearly define who they were as readers.
David and El seemed to me to be more advanced in their ability to articulate their thoughts than some high school students. At first, this made me a bit skeptical, but I came to understand that what they were doing was articulating the actions of other students who may not even understand what they are doing let alone their motives and influences. For example, David says, “And we’re borrowing from everything we see that we think is cool. I mean, like maybe this well fit on me. This will look cool on me; this kind of conversation, this kind of attitude” (p. 16). Not all students would be able to identify why they act the way they do. Reading David and El’s words depicts the necessity of identifying what is significant to each individual and how that shapes their identity, even if they can’t directly express it.
Pulling this out of students is essentially a different form of assessment that leads to necessary reflection of our teaching. After listening to El, Neilsen identifies the question of whether or not the school has provided models of female protagonists in literature and how this has affected how she defines herself. I’m not exactly sure how teachers can find the time to probe their students to the point where they reveal significant aspects of their identity based on their forms of literacy. Conferences and writing are the main avenues I would take.
Like any good piece of writing, Neilsen closed with questions instead of answers: “What do schools offer that incites desire in youth? What ways can schools be places where seeking home is encouraged?” “When does being aware and critical destroy the desire to move the world?” These are questions that she leaves us to answer, and sadly the answer to the first question in many cases in my opinion would be nothing. So it’s time to work on changing that, right? . . .
Understanding students’ many identities is the first step to this. It is impossible to know and understand everything that makes a person, but we can start by helping them identify the most important form of literacy in their lives.
Chapter 2:
In all of our readings thus far (except for maybe Push), I have not encountered any specific ways to help students who cannot decode, which is a primary interest of mine. So when O’Brien says that schools “provide practice in print strategies that struggling readers have never learned—more of the same in spite of the fact that the approaches, for a host of reasons, did not work earlier in these adolescents’ academic careers” (p 43), I wonder if he includes decoding here. If so, I’d like to know if and how multimediating helped students become better decoders.
I think the idea is great and would love to learn how to implement it, however, I’d like to see some statistical data if I’m going to start an after school video game club for students in a reading class. I can’t deny the power of using different forms of media. Still, I worry about the kid who although he can build a bridge and excels in this form of literacy, cannot decode a sentence.
I guess what I’m looking for is how exactly multimediating helped these students become better readers. I’m not saying that it didn’t, I just want to know how.
Chapter 5:
LOVED this chapter. It is so easy to misinterpret students’ actions and misjudge their personalities. The authors say that readers might think they are crazy for asking us to think about all of these aspects of our classroom, but we don’t have to videotape our students’ every moves and analyze them to create a more nurturing environment. Simply being aware of our tendency (and peers tendencies) to peg students as types and force them into roles can help us take responsibility for changing this. It’s all about awareness to me. Awareness of incongruencies in our “participant structure” and what the activity really calls for. Awareness of our own style of and stance on teaching.
Chapter 6:
Yay! Literacy currency again! I love that term.
The students’ works in this chapter were touching. It’s so powerful to see a person grow through writing.
I’m shifting back and forth on the “as if” framework. In some cases, if fits perfectly: “NF presented herself ‘as if’ she were confident and sure, yet she struggled with her identity” (p.116). But in other instances, it just doesn’t fit: “VR is able to focus on other issues that affect African Americans ‘as if’ there is more to being African American than a perpetual struggle with racism” (121). There is more to being African American than a perpetual struggle with racism, no as if.
Chapter 8:
This chapter didn’t catch me as the others did. Nevertheless, I was astonished that Fallen Angles was banned “because of its graphic depiction of war” (p. 147). War is graphic. How can we allow kids to see it first hand but not allow them to learn about it—the reality of it—before going into it? That is so absurd.
I had a student ask me the other day if Iraq was part of the U.S. It’s astonishing how far students can get without having any idea what is going on around them. This is a perfect example of why it is important to incorporate democratic citizenship with literacy.
I’m glad Harper and Bean added “take action” to Parker’s curriculum (p.157). That’s one of the most important steps.
Chapter 1:
“The text or texts, as the adolescents themselves, resist stasis and defy definition” (p.6). I love how true that is. This chapter seemed to attempt to define David and El in terms of their literate life at any particular point in their life, but they couldn’t be defined. Changes could be identified in the two, but there were so many different influences at any one time that it was impossible to clearly define who they were as readers.
David and El seemed to me to be more advanced in their ability to articulate their thoughts than some high school students. At first, this made me a bit skeptical, but I came to understand that what they were doing was articulating the actions of other students who may not even understand what they are doing let alone their motives and influences. For example, David says, “And we’re borrowing from everything we see that we think is cool. I mean, like maybe this well fit on me. This will look cool on me; this kind of conversation, this kind of attitude” (p. 16). Not all students would be able to identify why they act the way they do. Reading David and El’s words depicts the necessity of identifying what is significant to each individual and how that shapes their identity, even if they can’t directly express it.
Pulling this out of students is essentially a different form of assessment that leads to necessary reflection of our teaching. After listening to El, Neilsen identifies the question of whether or not the school has provided models of female protagonists in literature and how this has affected how she defines herself. I’m not exactly sure how teachers can find the time to probe their students to the point where they reveal significant aspects of their identity based on their forms of literacy. Conferences and writing are the main avenues I would take.
Like any good piece of writing, Neilsen closed with questions instead of answers: “What do schools offer that incites desire in youth? What ways can schools be places where seeking home is encouraged?” “When does being aware and critical destroy the desire to move the world?” These are questions that she leaves us to answer, and sadly the answer to the first question in many cases in my opinion would be nothing. So it’s time to work on changing that, right? . . .
Understanding students’ many identities is the first step to this. It is impossible to know and understand everything that makes a person, but we can start by helping them identify the most important form of literacy in their lives.
Chapter 2:
In all of our readings thus far (except for maybe Push), I have not encountered any specific ways to help students who cannot decode, which is a primary interest of mine. So when O’Brien says that schools “provide practice in print strategies that struggling readers have never learned—more of the same in spite of the fact that the approaches, for a host of reasons, did not work earlier in these adolescents’ academic careers” (p 43), I wonder if he includes decoding here. If so, I’d like to know if and how multimediating helped students become better decoders.
I think the idea is great and would love to learn how to implement it, however, I’d like to see some statistical data if I’m going to start an after school video game club for students in a reading class. I can’t deny the power of using different forms of media. Still, I worry about the kid who although he can build a bridge and excels in this form of literacy, cannot decode a sentence.
I guess what I’m looking for is how exactly multimediating helped these students become better readers. I’m not saying that it didn’t, I just want to know how.
Chapter 5:
LOVED this chapter. It is so easy to misinterpret students’ actions and misjudge their personalities. The authors say that readers might think they are crazy for asking us to think about all of these aspects of our classroom, but we don’t have to videotape our students’ every moves and analyze them to create a more nurturing environment. Simply being aware of our tendency (and peers tendencies) to peg students as types and force them into roles can help us take responsibility for changing this. It’s all about awareness to me. Awareness of incongruencies in our “participant structure” and what the activity really calls for. Awareness of our own style of and stance on teaching.
Chapter 6:
Yay! Literacy currency again! I love that term.
The students’ works in this chapter were touching. It’s so powerful to see a person grow through writing.
I’m shifting back and forth on the “as if” framework. In some cases, if fits perfectly: “NF presented herself ‘as if’ she were confident and sure, yet she struggled with her identity” (p.116). But in other instances, it just doesn’t fit: “VR is able to focus on other issues that affect African Americans ‘as if’ there is more to being African American than a perpetual struggle with racism” (121). There is more to being African American than a perpetual struggle with racism, no as if.
Chapter 8:
This chapter didn’t catch me as the others did. Nevertheless, I was astonished that Fallen Angles was banned “because of its graphic depiction of war” (p. 147). War is graphic. How can we allow kids to see it first hand but not allow them to learn about it—the reality of it—before going into it? That is so absurd.
I had a student ask me the other day if Iraq was part of the U.S. It’s astonishing how far students can get without having any idea what is going on around them. This is a perfect example of why it is important to incorporate democratic citizenship with literacy.
I’m glad Harper and Bean added “take action” to Parker’s curriculum (p.157). That’s one of the most important steps.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)