Sunday, September 30, 2007

Sporadic thoughts on Rosenblatt

As I was reading Literature as Exploration I couldn’t help but love so many sentences that Rosenblatt wrote with humor, tenacity, and great insight. But then I got to a point where it became apparent that I was struggling with reader response theory and my own traditional conceptions of reading.
At some point there’s bound to be a right and wrong interpretation of a text. Right? I keep thinking that because the idea of there being a "wrong" interpretation is bashed so often, I must be wrong in thinking that there can be a wrong. All interpretations are right. Still, my experience tells me that there will be people (me included) who will read something into a text that simply isn’t there. So my struggle was this: how do I balance reader response with the plainness of there being wrongness (if you’ll allow me to make up words)?
I remember my favorite English professor. He often criticized high school English teachers for their love of reader response and did not shy from saying, "ummm . . . no," to interpretations. However, I never felt like I had to read literature objectively or only look at it from historical or other perspectives. So what’s happening here? And as a teacher (eventually) what should so I do?
Then came the AHA! moment as I got to pages 71 and 72. Rosenblatt articulated my struggle, reaffirmed my gut feeling, and assured me that she’d tell me what to do. So here it is: "honest recognition of one’s own reaction is not in itself sufficient to ensure sound critical opinion. . . .For he can begin to achieve a sound approach to literature only when he reflects on his response to it, when he attempts to understand what in the work and in himself produced that reaction, and when he thoughtfully goes on to modify, reject, or accept it." (72)
Getting students to interact personally with the text is only step one. I didn’t see that. I saw black and white. I love stepping into the gray. What a wonderful sensation!


Okay, so I have not finished the book yet, but I I’m absolutely loving it so far. The only complaint I have is her use of the word "trashy" to describe magazines and comic books. Geez, what's with all these open-minded writers being so snotty?


In all efforts to rid English classrooms of summaries, I have never heard someone explain it so well:
"Someone else can read the newspaper or a scientific work for us and summarize it acceptably.
No one, however, can read a poem for us."(33).
That’s all there is to it. Although I recognize that science can be just as available to subjectivity (as Applebee described in his book), the essence of a poem cannot be captured in a summary the way a newspaper article can.


It seems I’m going backwards in the book. In the first chapter Rosenblatt focuses on psychology and characters. The question arises, "What are the basic human traits that persist despite social and cultural changes?" (12). My immediate thought was what a wonderful "conversation" on which to base a series of readings. It could incorporate classic and contemporary works, and, in my opinion, it is a question worth asking.

Alright, back to reading. I have a long way to go . . .

Sunday, September 23, 2007

Applebee, p.28, contd.

I forgot that at some point in high school we also listened to the first few pages of Huckleberry Fin just to hear what it would sound like. We never went any farther than that.

I didn't get to reflect on any of those memories, so here I go.

Thinking about this made me think of the "mentioning" teaching Applebee talks about (forgive me, I don't know where it is or what exactly it is called). My teachers seemed to want to mention as much as they could just so that we knew that these novels existed, and that they were the classics. So rarely did we read in high school, and it was even less often that what we read took us anywhere beyond literal meanings and giant packets of vocabulary.

It makes me wonder what is happening. I know the teachers were miserable, they knew we were miserable, so why not change. The more I read the more I realize that the pedagogy that I thought was contemporary has been around long enough for them to have picked it up somewhere. So what's going on here? I thought maybe Laredo lived in it's own terrible education bubble, but after looking into some Austin classrooms, I haven't seen much of a difference. Sorry for the reiteration, but what's happening here? For Juniors and Seniors in English who have passed the TAKS we certainly can't blame it all on teaching to the test. Can we?

Applebee - Glued English

Appleebee talks about the tendency of English to come "unglued" into parts (p. 59) and earlier (p.32) cites Clapp's recommendations for specific English tasks that students should learn to do (prepare speeches, read legal documents, etc.). I understand how English can be taught holistically and authentically without taking it apart, but how much should we try to fit into a class? Should we leave the preparation of speeches to speech teachers? Should there even be a speech class? I know I learned more about speaking in other classes than I did in my speech class.
Speech is easy to fit into English without separating it from the whole. But what about the more specific tasks like reading legal documents. This is, I would say, an important ability. But it wouldn't necessarily fit neatly into the conversation curriculum Applebee discusses. So I started thinking, is teaching kids how to read by using this type of curriculum enough? If we can teach them to think and be metacognitive without necessarily making an isolated lesson of metacognition can they take what they learned tacitly by doing and use it (tacitly) when reading a legal document?
I became a better learner when I learned more about teaching . . .

Applebee - p.28

Part of what I wanted to write last week but was too tired to think:

On page 28 Applebee lists the ten most frequently cited titles; this is what I remember about 6 of them in my high school experience.

1. Romeo and Juliet - In freshman English we spent several weeks on Romeo and Juliet, but don't ask me exactly what we did because we were NOT required to read it.

2. Julius Caesar - I had to teach Julius Caesar to Sophomores (most of them recent arrivals from Mexico). By teach, I mean I had to explain every single line to them. Just to be clear, this was not my idea. My mentor made sure I did exactly that.

3. To Kill a Mockingbird - In sophomore English we were allowed to pick our own books to read for a projects. The teacher begged someone to read it, explaining its status as a classic. I opted to read number 6 on my list . . .

4. Of Mice and Men - I read this when I was a freshman. Upon completion, I went to the school library, took a test containing entirely multiple choice questions about the book, passed it, and that was the end of it.

5. The Great Gatsby - This is my favorite. Junior English. One of the greatest American novels, says teacher. To celebrate its greatness, we watch the movie. Read? What does that mean?

6. Lord of the Flies - This was the book that I chose for my project. Completed the project and received an A without even reading the first page. I know, I'm ashamed.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Applebee . . . not really.

I had wonderful goals for Thursday night. I would read X amount of Applebee, write about what I read on my blog, and then retire into my bed. It didn't take long before a few comments about what I was reading turned into a heated discussion (alright, argument) about canonical literature. *Sigh.* I'm tired now. It's time for bed, and my brain isn't working as well as it should be. Applebee has proven to be a fun read.

I'll be away for the weekend . . . completely away from computers, but I'll be writing on paper and post as soon as I get home on Sunday.

Sunday, September 16, 2007

MYERS!!!

I thought I should wait until I finished the book to post any blogs. That was a silly, silly idea as I do not have one big thought about the book but several little ones.

To begin, midway through the book I thought it might have been fun to take a tally of every time Myers forewarned me, told me what his book was about, or used a question-answer writing style. How does one add links to a blog? One adds links to a blog by clicking on Template. Every time he did that I felt like I was reading an essay written by a fifth grader who was taught to entice the reader by asking questions.

Enough of that. Going back to the discussion on Monday about English being more than print text, I find it odd that at the very least pre-service teachers aren't including more electronic text in their teaching. I hadn't thought about the need to teach students to read different types of media in terms of the shift from decoding literacy. As much as I don't want to quote anything, I have to quote Myer's summarizing Blackmur:

"teaching decoding/analytic literacy was an inadequate standard for the schools in a contemporary democracy, arguing that understanding the literal meanings of printed materials was not enough for citizens in an age with a plethora of print and visual media. He observed that as long as citizens believe that 'saying so makes it so,' modern media could be used by despots to control populations" (114).

In the age MTV reality show teachers have an obligations to teach students how to read television, advertisements, Internet websites, etc. critically. This is not to say that as teachers we have to show Laguna Beach in our classrooms. We should, however, at least teach novels that address issues that our girls are being brainwashed to believe (e.g. to be beautiful one has to be blonde, thin, ditsy, and rich). We can use traditional print media to bring in discussions of every other medium that bombards our lives and minds without us realizing it.

To be fair, the TEKS does have a section on visual media for English language arts. Not being in the classroom currently, I don't know how teachers are addressing it. At least it's there.

Another detail I enjoyed in Changing Our Minds was the idea of reading a book for the first time with students. What a great idea! I can't imagine what it would be like. How would a teacher plan weekly lessons around this? I love the idea of modelling cognitive processes for the students in a truly authentic situation. When we plan so thoroughly for the teaching of a novel, I think we lose sight of how we formed our ideas. I'd love to do this, but there would definitely be an element of fear. Perhaps that fear would help me understand the students fear of taking risks and formulating ideas. That reminds me, when did guesstimate become an actual word? Anyhow, if anyone has ever done this, I'd love to know what it was like.

Here's a fun tidbit. I read the wine/water situation to my boyfriend to see how he would answer. He, like me, said that the water would contain more impurity. When I explained the correct answer and showed him the pictures he understood. He then explained to me that the reason he answered the way he did was because he thought about water being clear and being able to see the wine in the water and the wine being read and not being able to see the water in the wine. His idea of impurity was not that of chemical impurity. What threw him off, it seems, was using the words wine and water. If I had used A and B, his thought process may have been different. Like some of the teachers in Myers's study, the interference of real life did not allow him to think scientifically. Anyhow, that was fun for me.

As a whole, I thought Myers aligned the economic aspects/changes in literacy with the scholastic aspects/changes in literacy very well. I always hear people say that reading is essential in the job force, and though I have never disagreed with this, I have also never been able to explicitly show the relationship, as Myer's does. Despite his stylistic annoyances, Myer's does a good job of smushing a lot of ideas into a relatively small book.

Thursday, September 6, 2007

blog for class

This is a blog for class.